Another NFL season lurks right around the corner, and I assume that you’re already knee deep in preparing for your upcoming fantasy football draft(s). If not, have no fear, as this draft guide can help accelerate your preparation.
First, in as few words as possible, here’s a quick-hits analysis of the different fantasy football positions this year: QB - key; RB - uncertainty; WR - deep; TE - also deep; DEF - normal; K - j/k.
Now to expand on the quick-hits analysis, this year appears to be the year of the quarterback in fantasy football. If you can get your hands on one of the elite quarterback, you should pounce on the opportunity. The difference between the top QB, Aaron Rodgers, and a mid-level QB, let’s say Matt Ryan, is staggering. With passing levels at an all time high in the NFL, an elite QB can carry your team in fantasy football.
In looking at running backs this season, you have a few safe, productive players, and the rest facing time shares and/or injury concerns. Unless you can grab one of the elite RBs, it may be worthwhile to draft for quantity and see if you hit a few home runs.
We have an especially deep wide receiver position, with great value deep into the draft. The tight end position also looks to be as deep as ever, and you can get a solid TE later in the draft.
Returning to the draft guide, as per previous years, the rankings have been grouped by position into tiers. Always, always draft with the tier system as your base. I have also included a comprehensive top 150 ranking so you can see where QBs, RBs, WRs, etc. fit amongst each other.
For those new to the tier system, each player in the same tier is expected to be interchangeable for the most part. For example, I expect Tom Brady and Drew Brees to provide similar value this season. Whichever player is listed first within the tier is the player to whom I’d give the slight edge, but again I wouldn’t expect the difference to be much.
The tier system becomes especially valuable as you get deeper into the draft. When you’re trying to decide whether or not to go with a WR, RB or TE with your fourth round pick, take a look at the players remaining at the time at the highest remaining tier level for each position. Continuing the example, if several players remain in the WR and TE tiers, but only one or two RBs from the top remaining tier are still there, then consider taking the RB, as for your next draft pick, you’ll most likely be faced with selecting an RB from a lower tier.
Now keep in mind that you do need to have a grasp on where the players fit overall into the rankings, and as mentioned, I have provided you with a top 150 overall ranking list for this purpose. A QB in the third tier does not have equal value to a TE in the third tier, etc. So in making your draft selections, you should use the tier system as your base, and then cross-check the players against the overall rankings to make sure that the players you are comparing are in the vicinity of the draft slot you’re using.
One final important note to keep in mind is that these rankings are based on standard leagues (no points-per-reception, no TD only scoring system, etc.). If your league rules stray away from the norm, that’s fine, but just factor that into your rankings.
(Bye weeks for each player are in parentheses, and a few players whom I expect to outperform their draft slots are in bold).
Quarterback Tiers
Tier 1: Aaron Rodgers (10)
Tier 2: Tom Brady (9), Drew Brees (6)
Tier 3: Matthew Stafford (5), Cam Newton (6), Philip Rivers (7)
Tier 4: Eli Manning (7), Tony Romo (5), Michael Vick (7), Peyton Manning (11)
Tier 5: Ben Roethlisberger (4), Jay Cutler (6), Matt Schaub (8), Matt Ryan (7), Robert Griffin III (10)
Tier 6: Josh Freeman (5), Joe Flacco (8), Sam Bradford (9), Alex Smith (9), Andy Dalton (8), Carson Palmer (5)
Tier 7: Andrew Luck (4), Tim Tebow (9), Matt Flynn (11), Matt Cassel (7), Ryan Fitzpatrick (8), Christian Ponder (11), Kevin Kolb (10), Jake Locker (11)
Tier 8: Brandon Weeden (10), Mark Sanchez (9), Matt Moore (7)
Analysis:
Get your quarterback early if you can! If you can land a QB from one of the top three tiers, that would be ideal. Don’t sleep on Philip Rivers - he had one bad season, and now he’s dropped on fantasy boards much farther than he should. The QBs in Tier 4 have very high upside, but come with considerable health risk other than Eli Manning. Tucked away at the end of Tier 5 is RGIII, and I do feel that he will have an impact, but I do not see him putting up Cam Newton numbers - at least not this season. The Redskins face a tough schedule, and their O-line has issues. Still, he’s listed here in front of some solid QBs.
Running Back Tiers
Tier 1: Arian Foster (8), Ray Rice (8), LeSean McCoy (7), Chris Johnson (11)
Tier 2: Maurice Jones-Drew (6), Ryan Matthews (7), Darren McFadden (5)
Tier 3: Marshawn Lynch (11), Matt Forte (6), Trent Richardson (10), Jamaal Charles (7), Adrian Peterson (11), Steven Jackson (9), Fred Jackson (8)
Tier 4: DeMarco Murray (5), Michael Turner (7), Darren Sproles (6), Frank Gore (9), Ahmad Bradshaw (11)
Tier 5: Ben Tate (8), Roy Helu (10), Willis McGahee (7), Reggie Bush (7), Jonathan Stewart (6), Doug Martin (5)
Tier 6: Shonn Greene (9), CJ Spiller (8), Isaac Redman (4), Stevan Ridley (9), DeAngelo Williams (6)
Tier 7: Toby Gerhart (11), Jahvid Best (5), Beanie Wells (10), James Starks (10), Ryan Williams (10), Mikel Leshoure (5), Michael Bush (6), Mark Ingram (6), Felix Jones (5), BenJarvis Green-Ellis (8), Donald Brown (4), Shane Vereen (9), Peyton Hillis (7)
Tier 8: Pierre Thomas (6), David Wilson (11), LaGarrette Blount (5), Kevin Smith (5), Mike Goodson (5), Bernard Scott (8), Ronnie Hillman (7)
Analysis:
The top four RBs are all worthy of top overall pick consideration, along with Aaron Rodgers. I think Chris Johnson comes back with a vengeance this season. After Tier 1, I see a very uncertain group of RBs. From Tier 2, MJD’s holdout and more importantly, lack of help around him, and Matthews and Run DMC’s injury history provide cause for concern. However, in Run DMC’s case, if healthy, he’s talented enough to lead all RBs in total points. Tier 3 RBs are no sure bets either, although I’m a believer that Richardson, not facing an RB-by-committee, will put up good numbers. I’m not as high on DeMarco Murray and Michael Turner as others may be, and their placement in Tier 4 shows this. Overall, this year the RB position is very uncertain after the top options, and as such, if you do not land the Tier 1 guys, I strongly recommend taking flyers on a few talented, higher risk/reward guys, and also keeping a close eye on the waiver wire as the season goes on.
Wide Receivers Tiers
Tier 1: Calvin Johnson (5)
Tier 2: Larry Fitzgerald (10), AJ Green (8), Greg Jennings (10), Andre Johnson (8)
Tier 3: Mike Wallace (4), Julio Jones (7), Roddy White (7), Wes Welker (9), Jeremy Maclin (6), Brandon Marshall (7)
Tier 4: Jordy Nelson (10), Hakeem Nicks (11), Steve Smith (6), Dez Bryant (5), Miles Austin (5), Marques Colston (6), Victor Cruz (11), Dwayne Bowe (7)
Tier 5: Percy Harvin (11), Brandon Lloyd (9), Vincent Jackson (5), Eric Decker (7), Demaryius Thomas (7), Antonio Brown (4), Steve Johnson (8), Pierre Garcon (10), Denarius Moore (5)
Tier 6: Robert Meachem (7), Torrey Smith (8), DeSean Jackson (7), Kenny Britt (11), Sidney Rice (11), Santonio Holmes (9), Anquan Boldin (8), Reggie Wayne (4)
Tier 7: Mike Williams (5), Lance Moore (6), Michael Crabtree (9), Justin Blackmon (6), Greg Little (10), Leonard Hankerson (10), Doug Baldwin (11), Malcolm Floyd (7), Darius Heyward-Bay (50, Nate Washington (11), Laurent Robinson (6), James Jones (10), Titus Young (5), Santana Moss (10)
Tier 8: Nate Burleson (5), Mario Manningham (9), Randy Moss (9), Brian Quick (9), Michael Floyd (10), Danny Amendola (9), Rueben Randle (11), Kendall Wright (11), Brandon LaFell (6), Alshon Jeffrey (6)
Analysis:
I’m all in on AJ Green this season. I expect a monster season and a top 3 finish among WRs. I'm also a big fan of Julio Jones, and believe that he’ll outperform Roddy White, although they’ll be very close. Love those two receivers in their second NFL season. Jeremy Maclin is another WR who will return excellent value for those who draft him. A few other thoughts: Eric Decker over Demaryius Thomas, Dez Bryant over Miles Austin, and I expect Victor Cruz to put up solid numbers, but not the same level he posted last season. Overall, WR is a very deep position, and you will be able to find value deep into the draft.
Tight End Tiers
Tier 1: Rob Gronkowski (9), Jimmy Graham (6)
Tier 2: Antonio Gates (7), Vernon Davis (9)
Tier 3: Fred Davis (10), Jason Witten (5), Aaron Hernandez (9), Jermaine Gresham (8), Brandon Pettigrew (5), Jermichael Finley (10), Tony Gonzalez (7)
Tier 4: Jared Cook (11), Jacob Tamme (7)
Tier 5: Coby Fleener (4), Brent Celek (7), Owen Daniels (8), Martellus Bennett (11), Kellen Winslow (11)
Tier 6: Greg Olsen (6), Marcedes Lewis (6), Tony Moeaki (7), Kyle Rudolph (11), Heath Miller (4), Dallas Clark (5)
Analysis:
I’ve got Gronkowski and Graham listed as the tier 1 TEs, but you most likely won’t find them on my teams based on early draft returns, as they’re being selected too high for my taste. I expect both to have great years, but I don’t see repeats of last season. Gronk will have only 12 touchdowns this year. Like WR, the TE position is very deep this year. I even like the Tier 4 guys, so you can wait to get value in the later rounds. We’re looking at a terrific year for tight ends.
Kicker Tiers
Are you serious?! No rankings of kickers, ever. Select your kickers LAST.
Analysis:
Here are the reasons why you do NOT select kickers anywhere but with the last picks of your draft:
1. The variance between the top kickers and the kickers in the middle of the pack each season is not much (average of only two points a week).
2. If a kicker has an epic season, it will usually be random as to the identity of the kicker (translation: it could be anyone, so don’t try to guess who it is at the draft).
So when it comes to selecting your kickers, use your final picks, and just make sure that whoever you select does in fact start the season as the team’s field goal kicker, rather than just a kickoff specialist.
Defense/Special Teams Tiers
Tier 1: San Francisco (9)
Tier 2: Pittsburgh (4), Seattle (11), Baltimore (8), Chicago (6)
Tier 3: Houston (8), Philadelphia (7), New York Jets (9), Buffalo (8)
Tier 4: Detroit (5), Kansas City (7), Dallas (5), Atlanta (7), Green Bay (10), Arizona (10), New York Giants (11)
Tier 5: Cincinnati (8), St. Louis (9), Miami (7), New England (9), Tennessee (11), Washington (10), Cleveland (10), Denver (7)
Analysis:
Probably more than any other position, the importance of defense/special teams depends on your league’s point scoring system. In some leagues, defense/special teams make a big impact, and in other leagues, they make minimal impact. Make sure to know how much emphasis your league places on defensive/ST scoring prior to making your selection. San Francisco sits at the top of the tier structure, and otherwise the rankings are self-explanatory.
Conclusion/Final Advice:
You’ve got all the resources you need here to have another championship caliber fantasy football season. Remember not to force any picks - let the draft board come to you. Use the tier system provided here. Even if your rankings differ from those above, that’s fine, but abide by your tier system. And while it would be ideal to end up with one of the top QBs, don’t force it if the draft doesn’t play out that way. Stay true to your rankings, and know your scoring system well. This is key!!! If your league rewards points for each reception, or if your league’s scoring system heavily favors touchdown rather than yardage, draft with that in mind. One more piece of advice - on draft day, keep track of what positions each team has drafted. For example, knowing how many teams have already selected a TE can be very helpful - you may be able to hold off on picking one until later if everyone else has already picked one. The last piece of advice, and the most important - make sure to have fun!
Please feel free to email me with any thoughts or questions. I can be reached at [email protected].
Overall Top 150
1. Aaron Rodgers
2. Arian Foster
3. Ray Rice
4. LeSean McCoy
5. Chris Johnson
6. Tom Brady
7. Calvin Johnson
8. Drew Brees
9. Larry Fitzgerald
10. Matthew Stafford
11. Maurice Jones-Drew
12. Cam Newton
13. Ryan Mathews
14. Darren McFadden
15. Andre Johnson
16. Rob Gronkowski
17. AJ Green
18. Phillip Rivers
19. Jimmy Graham
20. Greg Jennings
21. Marshawn Lynch
22. Matt Forte
23. Trent Richardson
24. Mike Wallace
25. Julio Jones
26. Roddy White
27. Jamaal Charles
28. Wes Welker
29. Jeremy Maclin
30. Brandon Marshall
31. Adrian Peterson
32. Jordy Nelson
33. Hakeem Nicks
34. Eli Manning
35. Steven Jackson
36. Fred Jackson
37. Steve Smith (CAR)
38. Dez Bryant
39. Tony Romo
40. Michael Vick
41. Miles Austin
42. Demarco Murray
43. Michael Turner
44. Antonio Gates
45. Peyton Manning
46. Darren Sproles
47. Marques Colston
48. Vernon Davis
49. Victor Cruz
50. Dwayne Bowe
51. Frank Gore
52. Ahmad Bradshaw
53. Percy Harvin
54. Brandon Lloyd
55. Ben Tate
56. Ben Roethlisberger
57. Roy Helu
58. Jay Cutler
59. Vincent Jackson
60. Eric Decker
61. Fred Davis
62. Jason Witten
63. Willis McGahee
64. Reggie Bush
65. Matt Schaub
66. Aaron Hernandez
67. Matt Ryan
68. Demaryius Thomas
69. Jonathan Stewart
70. Doug Martin
71. Antonio Brown
72. Robert Griffin III
73. Steve Johnson
74. Pierre Garcon
75. Denarius Moore
76. Jermaine Gresham
77. Josh Freeman
78. CJ Spiller
79. Isaac Redman
80. Shonn Greene
81. Joe Flacco
82. Stevan Ridley
83. Robert Meachem
84. Torrey Smith
85. Brandon Pettigrew
86. Sam Bradford
87. DeAngelo Williams
88. DeSean Jackson
89. Kenny Britt
90. Alex Smith
91. Sidney Rice
92. Jermichael Finley
93. Andy Dalton
94. Tony Gonzalez
95. Toby Gerhart
96. Jahvid Best
97. Beanie Wells
98. Santonio Holmes
99. Anquan Boldin
100. Carson Palmer
101. James Starks
102. Ryan Williams
103. Reggie Wayne
104. San Francisco 49ers
105. Mikel Leshoure
106. Michael Bush
107. Jared Cook
108. Mark Ingram
109. Mike Williams
110. Andrew Luck
111. Felix Jones
112. Pittsburgh Steelers
113. Lance Moore
114. Michael Crabtree
115. Seattle Seahawks
116. Tim Tebow
117. Jacob Tamme
118. Justin Blackmon
119. BenJarvis Green-Ellis
120. Baltimore Ravens
121. Matt Flynn
122. Matt Cassel
123. Donald Brown
124. Chicago Bears
125. Shane Vereen
126. Greg Little
127. Leonard Hankerson
128. Doug Baldwin
129. Peyton Hillis
130. Ryan Fitzpatrick
131. Kevin Kolb
132. Houston Texans
133. Malcolm Floyd
134. Darius Heyward-Bay
135. Philadelphia Eagles
136. Jake Locker
137. Pierre Thomas
138. David Wilson
139. Nate Washington
140. Laurent Robinson
141. LaGarrette Blount
142. New York Jets
143. James Jones
144. Kevin Smith
145. Titus Young
146. Mike Goodson
147. Buffalo Bills
148. Santana Moss
149. Nate Burleson
150. Mario Manningham




