RealGM Football
Be An NFL GM Semifinals: Eli Vs. Bush
Authored by Paul Falewicz - 5th September, 2006 - 4:21 am

Red Zone Archives
28th Jul, 2011
Grading The Deal: Eagles Finally Send Kolb To Arizona

8th Apr, 2010
2010 NFL Consensus Mock Draft, Version 2.0

Full Archive

Current Featured Columns
$.07 For the Start of Preseason
Peyton Manning's Denver debut, the draft ramifications of Tyrann Mathieu, Jonathan Vilma's can't-lose situation, Usain Bolt as a wideout and more.

2012 Breakthroughs And Bounce-Backs
Philip Rivers and Chris Johnson are candidates to have bounce-back seasons, while J.J. Watt, Greg Little, Brooks Reed and Kyle Rudolph are poised to breakthrough.

Thoughts From The Road
While driving up and down America's heartland, Jeff Risdon weighs in on LaDainian Tomlinson, BCS provisions, Percy Harvin, Colt McCoy and Jerry Sandusky.

Opening Day Quarterback Starters
The NFL is living in a golden age of quarterbacks where the one common denominator of winning teams is a strong passing game.

The second final four match-up is between two of the NFL?s younger, and more promising, offensive players. Eli Manning has shown flashes of the brilliance the Giants hoped for when they got their hands on him just a few seasons ago. Meanwhile, the city of New Orleans has already anointed Reggie a Saint and he hasn?t even played an official down yet.

The Case For Eli

Eli showed a tremendous amount of progress last season, improving his quarterback rating by twenty points in 2005, while leading the Giants to a 11-5 record and a NFC East title. If he turns out to be a fraction of the player his brother has been, then he?s a good pick to start an NFL team. Being a quarterback bodes well for him in this contest. If Eli can advance past Bush, and his brother Peyton can vault past Brady, it would make for a thrilling Manning vs. Manning final later next week.

The Case Against Eli

He may forever be compared to his older brother, a comparison that isn?t fair to the younger Manning. Peyton is the most talented quarterback of his generation, and Eli may end up caving to the pressure that the media and fans have placed on him. If he continues to excel that won?t be a problem, but if he fails to improve this season, New Yorkers will be calling for his head. Reggie Bush holds an advantage over Eli because he brings an intangible feeling of excitement to the field that Manning doesn?t.

The Case For Reggie

Reggie Bush is one of the most hyped rookies in the history of the NFL, and rightfully so. He dazzled his way to the Heisman Trophy in his last season at USC, and just fell short of winning a national title against Vince Young and the Texas Longhorns. Bush is a freakish athlete whose athleticism is only matched by his blazing speed and cool charisma. He is the kind of player who could end up winning games, and putting millions of people in the stands at the same time.

The Case Against Reggie

He might be the most athletic of all NFL running backs, but Reggie?s yet to prove that he can be the most durable. At USC, he shared carries with fellow rookie LenDale White, and often handed the ball over to White near the end zone. The question remains as to whether Bush can carry a full rushing load in the NFL, and whether or not, he?s durable enough to keep going after he?s been tackled thirty times. The only advantage Eli has over Reggie is that quarterbacks have been the name of the game in our ?Be an NFL GM? contest thus far.

The choice is yours ? Who will make it to the RealGM Super Bowl?

Vote on our NFL main page to have your voice heard!

Also, submit your daily choice to Andrew.Perna@realgm.com in order to enter yourself in the running for a Mitchell & Ness Retro NFL Jersey from DistantReplays.com (a $300 value!).