Red Zone Archives
24th Jan, 2010
Blogging Through The AFC Title Game

7th Dec, 2009
Simultaneously Undefeated And Historical

Full Archive

NFL Columns
Search
RealGM Poll
Which team will win Super Bowl XLV?

Saints
Colts
Vikings
Steelers
Cowboys
Chargers
Packers
Ravens
Eagles
Patriots
Giants
Jets
Cardinals
Texans
Other



Poll Archives
Draft Sim ID
Sponsors

Don't miss your chance for football betting at BetUS.com. As America's #1 sportsbook, BetUS offers the most up-to-date betting lines & odds for all your betting needs.


Be The GM: Williams Vs. Manning
Authored by Andrew Perna - 26th August, 2009 - 9:43 am
Current Featured Columns
Rethinking Peyton Manning
Due to the advantages given to quarterbacks in this era and his war chest of first rounders on offense, Peyton Manning has become overrated.

$.06 After Super Bowl Week
Two plays that made the difference for the Saints, Tebow's ad, what the Saints should have done on 4th and goal and much more.

Spoiled Rotten
There’s a difference between a favorite and a lock. When up against a team with playoff-level talent, it’s rare that the team with the better record ever appears in the second category.

Grading The Deal: Jets Make Deal For Edwards
Braylon Edwards will join Jericho Cotchery to form an elite wideout tandem, at least on paper.


RealGM Search
Search:

This is one of the most intriguing matchups we've featured thus far, as the Texans drafted Mario Williams with stopping Peyton Manning in mind.

Houston made Williams the first overall pick in the 2006 NFL Draft, which at the time was a pretty controversial decision. Vince Young and Reggie Bush were the sexier picks, but Williams has arguably become the best professional of the three.

Williams hasn't had much success stopping Manning, but not many have.

Why Williams Is A Franchise Player

Williams has blossomed into an elite pass rusher, quickly eclipsing Reggie Bush and Vince Young in terms of success. He is incredibly athletic and often reminds me of a banging NBA power forward.

He has worked on his proficiency against the run as well, and showed great improvement during the 2008 season. I hate to continue the comparisons with Bush and Young, vastly different players (obviously), but Williams hasn't had the physical health issues of the Saints running back or the mental health issues of the Titans quarterback.

The defensive end already has 30.5 sacks in his career, including a combined total of 26 in the last two years.

Why Manning Is A Franchise Player

In a few decades, you'll be able to tell your kids (or grand kids) that you had the pleasure of watching Peyton Manning play perhaps the best football we've ever seen from a quarterback.

He's had many a record-setting season, but his efforts in 2008 were especially impressive. The numbers weren't eye-popping, but he was able to lead the Colts to yet another playoff appearance after offseason surgery, problems on the offensive line and the regression of good buddy Marvin Harrison.

Only three players have more touchdown passes in NFL history, and he'll likely pass Fran Tarkenton for third place in the first half of the 2009 season. With Brett Favre lingering longer than expected, it's becoming more and more unlikely that Peyton will finish at the top of the TD list, but his passer rating is much better and ranks second all-time.


Click here to cast your vote and here to read the opening article


Andrew Perna is Deputy Editor of RealGM.com and co-host of RealGM's Radio Show. Please feel free to contact him with comments or questions via e-mail: Andrew.Perna@RealGM.com
All content © 2000-2010 RealGM, L.L.C. All rights reserved..
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Advertising Opportunities | About Us | Site Map | Contact RealGM