Archives
3rd Sep, 2009
How To Lose An NFL Coaching Job In Nine Months

18th Aug, 2009
How Vick's Success Could End McNabb's Career In Philly

Full Archive

NFL Columns
Search
RealGM Poll
Which team will win the AFC West?

Chargers
Broncos



Poll Archives
Draft Sim ID
Sponsors

Don't miss your chance for football betting at BetUS.com. As America's #1 sportsbook, BetUS offers the most up-to-date betting lines & odds for all your betting needs.


What A Difference A Wedge Makes
17th October, 2009 - 10:06 pm
Current Features
TEAM RANKINGS:
NFL Power Rankings For Week 11
The Colts have deservingly overtaken the Saints in our rankings with the Patriots holding steady in the third position. How do the NFL's other 29 teams rank?

STANDING 10:
The Staying Game
If Sam Bradford could do things over, he probably would have entered the draft in ’09. What does his decision mean for future collegiate stars and how will his own NFL future be affected?

PLAYER RANKINGS:
The Final NFL Player Rankings For 2008
If you remove the illusions of name, reputation, media market, etc., what do you get when looking at the 2008 NFL season? With the Field Impact Counter and the Reina Value it is possible.

LOCKER TALK:
Brady: Injury Was A Blessing In Disguise
Tom Brady has watched his Patriots fight their way to a 5-3 record through the first half of the season, and in actuality, he's pretty darn happy with where he currently stands.

MARCUS ALLEN:
How GMs Build Winning Rosters
While everyone focuses on the marquee players that will be drafted on day one this Saturday, the key to building a winning team is by acquiring 5-7 impact makers. It was Marques Colston last year, who will it be this year?


RealGM Search
Search:

By Randolph Charlotin

It happened on national television. It may not had been the first time, but it happened when all football fans could see it.

During the Sunday Night Football game, Indianapolis was penalized during a kickoff return for forming a blocking wedge. Before the season, the NFL made the blocking wedge illegal. The penalty cost the Colts half the distance in field position.

From the moment the NFL banned the wedge, there was debate over how the new rule would affect kickoff returns. Some experts believed it would help the return team.

Pete Cronan disagreed. Cronan, a former NFL linebacker with nine years of experience, played special teams with the Seattle Seahawks and Washington Redskins. He believed there would be less big returns.

Click here for Cronan’s X’s and O’s breakdown of the difference between the wedge and no wedge.

The season is only five weeks old, but is there a clear difference between this year and last?

Through five weeks, there have been three kickoff returns for touchdowns: Minnesota’s Percy Harvin in Week 3, and two in Week 4 with Chicago’s Johnny Knox and Houston’s Jacoby Jones taking it to the house.

While in 2008, Dallas’ Felix Jones and San Diego’s Darren Sproles went the distance in Week 2. Edge: 2009.

By average, ’09 is slightly ahead. The Bears have the best return game with a 31.3 average. Tennessee was the top regular season return team in ’08 with an average of 25.4 yards. But this is inconclusive as this is comparing five games against a full season.

The same can be said of the league average, though the difference is slight. After five games, 2009 averages 23 yards per return. 2008 managed 22.8.

A look at the top five returners might be more telling:

2008 - 30 returns minimum
Chi: Danieal Manning 29.7
NE: Ellis Hobbs, 28.5
Buf: Leodis McKelvin, 28.2
Ten: Chris Carr, 28.1
TB: Clifton Smith, 27.6

2009 - 10 returns minimum
Min: Percy Harvin, 31.2
Hou: Jacoby Jones, 29.6
SD: Darren Sproles, 28.5
TB: Clifton Smith, 28.1
Pit: Stephan Logan, 26.4

The 2009 has the edge, but this again repeats the problem of comparing five games against a 16-game regular season. This is thrown out as well.

Something starts to develop when comparing the first five games in each season. But instead of comparing averages, the measurement is big returns. Two standards were set: returns between 40-49 yards, and returns of 50 yards or more. Both were counted for the first five weeks of the season. Under these standards, 2008 leads 2009.

Last year, 20 returns gained between 40-49 yards after five weeks. That’s not a big deal considering there have been 18 returns of equal distance this year. But when the standard is raised to 50 yards or more, it becomes clear.

After five weeks, 2008 had 21 returns of 50 yards or more. 2009 lags well behind with 14 returns of 50 yards or more.

So even though the return average is higher in 2009, the number of big returns has gone down. These results aren’t conclusive, as the final tally at the end of the season will prove if the trend holds true. But if the these early returns keep this pace, then teams will continue to lose field position without the wedge.

Read more by Randolph Charlotin at his New England Patriots blog at . He can be reached at talktome@randolphc.com.
© 2000-2009 RealGM, L.L.C. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Advertising Opportunities | About Us | Site Map | Contact RealGM